Wood and Adam (in their capacity as Liquidators of Gold & General Limited) and others v Khumal and others: [2026] JRC 202

November 17, 2026

The proceedings were brought by the liquidators of Gold & General Limited (Gold and General) which was in a creditors winding up. The liquidators alleged that in October 2021, Gold and General transferred its principal asset, namely an 84% shareholding in Metallon Corporation Limited (Metallon) to one of its directors, a Mr Khumalo (Mr Khumalo), for no consideration.  Metallon itself held substantial interests in mining and telecommunication assets.  The shares in Metallon were subsequently transferred into a trust structure (the Trust Structure) for the benefit of Mr Khumalo and his family.  The liquidators sought relief under Article 176 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991 as a transaction at an undervalue, and alternatively, damages for breach of directors’ duties under Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.

‍

The defendants were resident outside Jersey, with Mr Khumalo residing in Switzerland and a Mr Sikwila (another former director of Gold and General) (Mr Sikwila) resident in South Africa, and the trustee of the Trust Structure, being a private company registered in New Zealand. The Court reviewed in detail the steps taken by the liquidators to effect service abroad, including Hague Convention service in Switzerland, substituted service in South African and extensive notification efforts through correspondence, company offices and Gazette notices.  Although the defendants had ample opportunity to participate in the proceedings, none filed a substantive defence or made any application to dispute the jurisdiction of the Court. The Court was satisfied that the defendants has been properly served and had either submitted to the jurisdiction or failed to challenge it.

‍

Rather than seeking default judgment, the liquidators pursued summary judgment.  The Court approved that course, adopting English authorities recognising that a claimant may seek a judgment on the merits against a non-participating defendant where proper service has been effected and the defendant has elected not to engage.  The Court accepted that a merits based judgment may assist enforcement in foreign jurisdictions and considered this a proper basis for the application.

‍

Turning to the substance of the dispute, the Court found that the transfer of Gold and General’s shareholding in Metallon occurred within the statutory five year period and that because Mr Khumalo was a connected party and director, the statutory presumption concerning insolvency applied.  In any event, the evidence demonstrates that Gold and General had failed to satisfy a substantial debt owed to a Sir Samual Jonah and was cash flow insolvent at the time of the transfer.  No evidence was advanced capable of establishing the statutory defence that the transfer had been entered into in good faith and for the benefit of Gold and General.

‍

In relation to directors’ duties, the Court held that the transfer represented a clear breach of Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.  The transfer had conferred no benefit on Gold and General, depleted Gold and General’s assets and operated to the detriment of its creditors.  The Court described the transaction as a “straightforward misappropriation” of company assets.  It concluded that Mr Khumalo had no realistic prospect of defending either the Article 176 claim or the Article 74 claim.

‍

The Court also imposed liability on Mr Sikwila. Although the Court noted uncertainty as to whether Article 176 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991 could support relief against a director who had not personally received the transferred asset, it found that liability was plainly justified under Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.  As fellow director, Mr Sikwila had either actively facilitated the transfer or negligently failed to prevent it. The Court concluded that Mr Sikwila had been, at best “asleep at the wheel” and had failed to exercise the level of care, diligence and skill expected of a reasonably prudent director.

‍

An important aspect of the judgment concerned valuation.  Having reviewed administration reports, company accounts, public filings and evidence relating to the underlying mining assets, the Court accepted the liquidators’ valuation evidence and assess the value of the Metallon shares by reference to the date of transfer rather than a later date. It concluded that the proper compensatory figure was £77,041,670 representing the estimated value of the Metallon shares.  

‍

The judgment is a significant affirmation of the Court’s willingness to scrutinise transfers of assets to connected parties, draw adverse inferences from absent evidence and impose substantial personal liability on directors who facilitate or permit transactions that prejudice creditors.

‍

The proceedings were brought by the liquidators of Gold & General Limited (Gold and General) which was in a creditors winding up. The liquidators alleged that in October 2021, Gold and General transferred its principal asset, namely an 84% shareholding in Metallon Corporation Limited (Metallon) to one of its directors, a Mr Khumalo (Mr Khumalo), for no consideration.  Metallon itself held substantial interests in mining and telecommunication assets.  The shares in Metallon were subsequently transferred into a trust structure (the Trust Structure) for the benefit of Mr Khumalo and his family.  The liquidators sought relief under Article 176 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991 as a transaction at an undervalue, and alternatively, damages for breach of directors’ duties under Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.

‍

The defendants were resident outside Jersey, with Mr Khumalo residing in Switzerland and a Mr Sikwila (another former director of Gold and General) (Mr Sikwila) resident in South Africa, and the trustee of the Trust Structure, being a private company registered in New Zealand. The Court reviewed in detail the steps taken by the liquidators to effect service abroad, including Hague Convention service in Switzerland, substituted service in South African and extensive notification efforts through correspondence, company offices and Gazette notices.  Although the defendants had ample opportunity to participate in the proceedings, none filed a substantive defence or made any application to dispute the jurisdiction of the Court. The Court was satisfied that the defendants has been properly served and had either submitted to the jurisdiction or failed to challenge it.

‍

Rather than seeking default judgment, the liquidators pursued summary judgment.  The Court approved that course, adopting English authorities recognising that a claimant may seek a judgment on the merits against a non-participating defendant where proper service has been effected and the defendant has elected not to engage.  The Court accepted that a merits based judgment may assist enforcement in foreign jurisdictions and considered this a proper basis for the application.

‍

Turning to the substance of the dispute, the Court found that the transfer of Gold and General’s shareholding in Metallon occurred within the statutory five year period and that because Mr Khumalo was a connected party and director, the statutory presumption concerning insolvency applied.  In any event, the evidence demonstrates that Gold and General had failed to satisfy a substantial debt owed to a Sir Samual Jonah and was cash flow insolvent at the time of the transfer.  No evidence was advanced capable of establishing the statutory defence that the transfer had been entered into in good faith and for the benefit of Gold and General.

‍

In relation to directors’ duties, the Court held that the transfer represented a clear breach of Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.  The transfer had conferred no benefit on Gold and General, depleted Gold and General’s assets and operated to the detriment of its creditors.  The Court described the transaction as a “straightforward misappropriation” of company assets.  It concluded that Mr Khumalo had no realistic prospect of defending either the Article 176 claim or the Article 74 claim.

‍

The Court also imposed liability on Mr Sikwila. Although the Court noted uncertainty as to whether Article 176 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991 could support relief against a director who had not personally received the transferred asset, it found that liability was plainly justified under Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.  As fellow director, Mr Sikwila had either actively facilitated the transfer or negligently failed to prevent it. The Court concluded that Mr Sikwila had been, at best “asleep at the wheel” and had failed to exercise the level of care, diligence and skill expected of a reasonably prudent director.

‍

An important aspect of the judgment concerned valuation.  Having reviewed administration reports, company accounts, public filings and evidence relating to the underlying mining assets, the Court accepted the liquidators’ valuation evidence and assess the value of the Metallon shares by reference to the date of transfer rather than a later date. It concluded that the proper compensatory figure was £77,041,670 representing the estimated value of the Metallon shares.  

‍

The judgment is a significant affirmation of the Court’s willingness to scrutinise transfers of assets to connected parties, draw adverse inferences from absent evidence and impose substantial personal liability on directors who facilitate or permit transactions that prejudice creditors.

‍

The proceedings were brought by the liquidators of Gold & General Limited (Gold and General) which was in a creditors winding up. The liquidators alleged that in October 2021, Gold and General transferred its principal asset, namely an 84% shareholding in Metallon Corporation Limited (Metallon) to one of its directors, a Mr Khumalo (Mr Khumalo), for no consideration.  Metallon itself held substantial interests in mining and telecommunication assets.  The shares in Metallon were subsequently transferred into a trust structure (the Trust Structure) for the benefit of Mr Khumalo and his family.  The liquidators sought relief under Article 176 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991 as a transaction at an undervalue, and alternatively, damages for breach of directors’ duties under Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.

‍

The defendants were resident outside Jersey, with Mr Khumalo residing in Switzerland and a Mr Sikwila (another former director of Gold and General) (Mr Sikwila) resident in South Africa, and the trustee of the Trust Structure, being a private company registered in New Zealand. The Court reviewed in detail the steps taken by the liquidators to effect service abroad, including Hague Convention service in Switzerland, substituted service in South African and extensive notification efforts through correspondence, company offices and Gazette notices.  Although the defendants had ample opportunity to participate in the proceedings, none filed a substantive defence or made any application to dispute the jurisdiction of the Court. The Court was satisfied that the defendants has been properly served and had either submitted to the jurisdiction or failed to challenge it.

‍

Rather than seeking default judgment, the liquidators pursued summary judgment.  The Court approved that course, adopting English authorities recognising that a claimant may seek a judgment on the merits against a non-participating defendant where proper service has been effected and the defendant has elected not to engage.  The Court accepted that a merits based judgment may assist enforcement in foreign jurisdictions and considered this a proper basis for the application.

‍

Turning to the substance of the dispute, the Court found that the transfer of Gold and General’s shareholding in Metallon occurred within the statutory five year period and that because Mr Khumalo was a connected party and director, the statutory presumption concerning insolvency applied.  In any event, the evidence demonstrates that Gold and General had failed to satisfy a substantial debt owed to a Sir Samual Jonah and was cash flow insolvent at the time of the transfer.  No evidence was advanced capable of establishing the statutory defence that the transfer had been entered into in good faith and for the benefit of Gold and General.

‍

In relation to directors’ duties, the Court held that the transfer represented a clear breach of Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.  The transfer had conferred no benefit on Gold and General, depleted Gold and General’s assets and operated to the detriment of its creditors.  The Court described the transaction as a “straightforward misappropriation” of company assets.  It concluded that Mr Khumalo had no realistic prospect of defending either the Article 176 claim or the Article 74 claim.

‍

The Court also imposed liability on Mr Sikwila. Although the Court noted uncertainty as to whether Article 176 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991 could support relief against a director who had not personally received the transferred asset, it found that liability was plainly justified under Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.  As fellow director, Mr Sikwila had either actively facilitated the transfer or negligently failed to prevent it. The Court concluded that Mr Sikwila had been, at best “asleep at the wheel” and had failed to exercise the level of care, diligence and skill expected of a reasonably prudent director.

‍

An important aspect of the judgment concerned valuation.  Having reviewed administration reports, company accounts, public filings and evidence relating to the underlying mining assets, the Court accepted the liquidators’ valuation evidence and assess the value of the Metallon shares by reference to the date of transfer rather than a later date. It concluded that the proper compensatory figure was £77,041,670 representing the estimated value of the Metallon shares.  

‍

The judgment is a significant affirmation of the Court’s willingness to scrutinise transfers of assets to connected parties, draw adverse inferences from absent evidence and impose substantial personal liability on directors who facilitate or permit transactions that prejudice creditors.

‍

The proceedings were brought by the liquidators of Gold & General Limited (Gold and General) which was in a creditors winding up. The liquidators alleged that in October 2021, Gold and General transferred its principal asset, namely an 84% shareholding in Metallon Corporation Limited (Metallon) to one of its directors, a Mr Khumalo (Mr Khumalo), for no consideration.  Metallon itself held substantial interests in mining and telecommunication assets.  The shares in Metallon were subsequently transferred into a trust structure (the Trust Structure) for the benefit of Mr Khumalo and his family.  The liquidators sought relief under Article 176 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991 as a transaction at an undervalue, and alternatively, damages for breach of directors’ duties under Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.

‍

The defendants were resident outside Jersey, with Mr Khumalo residing in Switzerland and a Mr Sikwila (another former director of Gold and General) (Mr Sikwila) resident in South Africa, and the trustee of the Trust Structure, being a private company registered in New Zealand. The Court reviewed in detail the steps taken by the liquidators to effect service abroad, including Hague Convention service in Switzerland, substituted service in South African and extensive notification efforts through correspondence, company offices and Gazette notices.  Although the defendants had ample opportunity to participate in the proceedings, none filed a substantive defence or made any application to dispute the jurisdiction of the Court. The Court was satisfied that the defendants has been properly served and had either submitted to the jurisdiction or failed to challenge it.

‍

Rather than seeking default judgment, the liquidators pursued summary judgment.  The Court approved that course, adopting English authorities recognising that a claimant may seek a judgment on the merits against a non-participating defendant where proper service has been effected and the defendant has elected not to engage.  The Court accepted that a merits based judgment may assist enforcement in foreign jurisdictions and considered this a proper basis for the application.

‍

Turning to the substance of the dispute, the Court found that the transfer of Gold and General’s shareholding in Metallon occurred within the statutory five year period and that because Mr Khumalo was a connected party and director, the statutory presumption concerning insolvency applied.  In any event, the evidence demonstrates that Gold and General had failed to satisfy a substantial debt owed to a Sir Samual Jonah and was cash flow insolvent at the time of the transfer.  No evidence was advanced capable of establishing the statutory defence that the transfer had been entered into in good faith and for the benefit of Gold and General.

‍

In relation to directors’ duties, the Court held that the transfer represented a clear breach of Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.  The transfer had conferred no benefit on Gold and General, depleted Gold and General’s assets and operated to the detriment of its creditors.  The Court described the transaction as a “straightforward misappropriation” of company assets.  It concluded that Mr Khumalo had no realistic prospect of defending either the Article 176 claim or the Article 74 claim.

‍

The Court also imposed liability on Mr Sikwila. Although the Court noted uncertainty as to whether Article 176 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991 could support relief against a director who had not personally received the transferred asset, it found that liability was plainly justified under Article 74 of the Companies (Jersey) Law 1991.  As fellow director, Mr Sikwila had either actively facilitated the transfer or negligently failed to prevent it. The Court concluded that Mr Sikwila had been, at best “asleep at the wheel” and had failed to exercise the level of care, diligence and skill expected of a reasonably prudent director.

‍

An important aspect of the judgment concerned valuation.  Having reviewed administration reports, company accounts, public filings and evidence relating to the underlying mining assets, the Court accepted the liquidators’ valuation evidence and assess the value of the Metallon shares by reference to the date of transfer rather than a later date. It concluded that the proper compensatory figure was £77,041,670 representing the estimated value of the Metallon shares.  

‍

The judgment is a significant affirmation of the Court’s willingness to scrutinise transfers of assets to connected parties, draw adverse inferences from absent evidence and impose substantial personal liability on directors who facilitate or permit transactions that prejudice creditors.

‍